Persil ProClean Put to the Test – First Impressions and Review

Persil ProClean Review

Persil ProClean is now available at Walmart

A high value $3 off coupon is currently available here, however make sure to print it out asap, since it most likely won’t last long.
More coupons available as of May 24th! Check out Persil coupons.

As you probably already know, I am a huge fan of German Persil and got very excited last week when the launch of Persil ProClean was announced in the US. Unfortunately, none of my local Walmarts were carrying the Persil ProClean line yet, so I reached out the the folks at ProClean and they were kind enough to send me some samples. I received them yesterday and of course had to put the US version of Persil to the test straight away! Here are my first impressions, and I will be doing a full comprehensive review after I’ve used the detergents for a while.

Edit June 5, 2015: Consumer Reports has named Persil ProClean 2-in-1 liquid their #1 top rated detergent! Read more here.

I have to start out by saying that I did not go easy on Persil ProClean. The German version is an outstanding detergent, so the bar was set very high. In fact, I actually put the ProClean through even more than I would regularly subject German Persil to just to see how it would do.

I started out by asking my husband to wear two identical white dress shirts a couple of days longer than he normally would, and fortunately he agreed. The result? Gross, set in collar and cuff grime, yellow perspiration stains and varietal coffe/ink stains on the shirts. Here’s a “before” picture so you know I’m not exaggerating:

Persil ProClean before

Gross! Quite a test for Persil ProClean

Now, normally I would do the following with a shirt this dirty: first wet the cuffs and collar with warm water and pretreat with Ecover stain remover, using the brush to really get the product into the stains, then set aside for 30 minutes. After that do a prewash (Miele calls this “Heavy Soil”) with Biz and use the Extra White/Hot (60C/140F) settings on my Miele W3038 with 3 Tbsp of Persil Universal Megaperls and an added 1 Tbsp of sodium percarbonate. The Extra White setting is great for stain removal, since it’s quite long and the clothes are tumbled fairly aggressively, and along with Custom it’s one of my favorites for heavily soiled/stained clothes.

MORE FROM OLGA’S LAUNDRY  iHerb vs Vitacost: Which Is Better? My Review

But I wanted to really push the Persil ProClean, so I did not give it nearly as much help as I normally would my regular detergent. I chose to use only Persil ProClean products (so no other additives), and decided to experiment even further by pretreating the collar and cuffs of one shirt with some ProClean liquid, and washing the other without pretreating. I did not use warm water or a brush, just applied the liquid to dry fabric, pushed it in with my finger and let it sit for about 5 minutes.

Persil ProClean Review

One shirt got pretreated with some Persil ProClean liquid, the other didn’t. I buttoned the gauntlet buttons of the untreated one to tell them apart.

I then chose to use about 2 Tbsp of the Persil ProClean Original liquid as a prewash (“Heavy Soil”) and 3 Tbsp of the Power Pearls for the main wash.

Persil ProClean dosage

I used about as much product as I would with German Persil.

I then decided to use the Wrinkle Free setting – it is a shorter cycle with less aggressive tumbling than the Extra White that I would normally use, and set it to Very Warm (50C/122F), since that is the hottest most standard US washing machines will go. I also added an extra rinse, since that is my standard MO.

Persil ProClean laundry

By choosing cooler water and a less aggressive cleaning cycle I wanted to eliminate as much “Miele bias” as possible and see how the ProClean would work in a regular machine

Note to self: the liquid is fairly thick, so next time I won’t use the liquid dispenser insert – it didn’t wash out of it well. However, in spite of that the overall results were pretty amazing!

Persil ProClean results

The top dress shirt was pretreated with Persil ProClean liquid, and the bottom was not

The pretreating made a huge difference in the collars – the shirt that I had poured some Persil ProClean Original Liquid on before the wash came out virtually spotless. The dress shirt that I washed as is had some very faint stains left over.

Persil ProClean collar

Collars compared after washing with Persil ProClean: the top collar was briefly pretreated with ProClean liquid, the bottom was washed as is

However the cuffs came out spotless on both shirts, so next time I won’t bother pretreating those.

Persil ProClean cuff

The top cuff was pretreated with ProClean liquid, the bottom was washed as is

Overall, I am VERY impressed with the new Persil ProClean line! I will be posting a more thorough review once I’ve used it for a couple of weeks, however I already know that it’s a great detergent that can finally provide some real competition for Tide. The price points for the two detergents are similar: you can get a small, 20 load bottle of liquid for around $5, a 50 load bottle for around $10 and a large 96 load pump bottle for $18; Persil ProClean is currently sold only at Walmart both in-store and online. Persil ProClean is now available at a number of retailers in the US. I’ve seen the detergent at CVS and RiteAid, as well as at a number of supermarkets and of course on Amazon.

Persil ProClean before

Once again, here is what I started out with…

Persil ProClean after

…and here are the results of washing with Persil ProClean!

And now some notes for German Persil lovers on how Persil ProClean compares: the scent is similar but not identical, and stronger than of the German detergent (and it airs out well, unlike Tide). All Persil ProClean formulas contain optical brighteners and the Power Pearls contain sodium percarbonate and TAED. The Pearls contain zeolytes. The formulas of the DE and US versions are not identical – fortunately the ProClean folks list the ingredients on the website so you can compare. It’s also a little more prone to sudsing, probably to accommodate the US top loader consumer who is used to seeing more froth during the wash. The Pearls come in a plastic bottle which I find very convenient (you can take out the pouring spout), however the measuring lines on the lid are impossible to read, so I measured the recommended amounts, and they indicate 3 Tbsp for a regular load and 5 Tbsp for a large/heavy load for both the Pearls and liquid – this corresponds to about how much German Persil I was using per load.

MORE FROM OLGA’S LAUNDRY  Perwoll Black Laundry Detergent Review

Have you already tried the new Persil ProClean line? Do you plan on trying it out? I’d love to hear your thoughts!

The Persil brand kindly provided me with samples of Persil ProClean laundry detergent, however all opinions expressed are my own.

 

23 thoughts on “Persil ProClean Put to the Test – First Impressions and Review

  1. Sherry says:

    I am thrilled to find your blog! Another sister in laundry chemistry! Yeah!! I have been using the new Persil ProClean (Walmart) and really like it. I’m a commited Tide groupie of many years but think I may have to convert! I do have a question. I have noticed my clothes seem much more wrinkled than usual. I typically fluff my husband’s shirts (Brooks Bros) in the dryer & then hang. Same with pants, jeans, etc. Everything seems stiffer & more wrinkled. I have meticulously measured the Persil so as to not use too much. Any thoughts? This is specific to clothes washed with Persil. (oh, and I double rinse everything)

    • Cranraspberry says:

      Hi Sherry! How exciting to find another fellow laundry nerd!!
      Have you been using the pearls or the liquid? I have a theory that zeolytes in the powder/pearls really contribute to stiffness in clothes, and also make them more prone to wrinkling. However liquid doesn’t contain zeolytes, so if you’re getting that issue with the liquid it could be the lack of some type of polymer that Tide contains that softens clothing.

      • Sherry says:

        Thank you for your response! I’m using the liquid Persil (blue in color). I agree with your remarks about the polymers. I have added a small amount of liquid Tide, which seems to significantly decrease the wrinkles. While I love how clean my clothes seem to be from the Persil, the wrinkles are a deal breaker. We do not have a young family or careers in which our clothes are super dirty. Thus, I’ll continue to use the Persil, mixing it with Tide. Do you know if the Persil (not sure what they call it, the perfume free one) is as effective as the regular Persil?

        • Cranraspberry says:

          Oh how great that you’ve figured out a solution! And a brilliant one at that.

          As for the Sensitive Persil, it’s actually not perfume free… They claim to have a “hypoallergenic perfume” added, which is quite the oxymoron. The ingredients lists look to be about the same, although the Sensitive does have an extra polymer added. I got pretty excited at first, thinking that it might solve your wrinkling issues, but a quick google search showed that it’s just there to impart the milky look. Boo!
          I myself haven’t tried it yet – it doesn’t come in small 20 load bottles, and I prefer to test a new detergent out first before investing in a large package. Let me know if you end up giving it a try!

  2. TF says:

    I solved the filthy collar problem by (a) making my husband use soap and a washcloth to clean his neck and (b) going over his neck with a cotton ball with a little alcohol on it, Voila! Problem solved, just regular laundering required,

  3. Jeanine says:

    I haven’t done any laundry soap testing since I was in middle school and did a comparison for a science experiment. In that test, Era won out over Tide, Cheer and Whisk. But that was over 20 years ago, so I’m sure advances in detergents have been made. What are your thoughts on Era? I’m very interested to try Persil. Which do you think cleans the best; the dry or liquid? I have 3 young children who are very messy eaters and a husband who has a penchant for dripping food on his shirts. I’m terrible at pre-treating his clothes and sometimes have to rewash his shirts because he’s found a stain after it’s been washed and dried. The rewash with a pretreat of Shout or Era usually solves the problem, but it’s such a pain to have to rewash everything. Thanks for your advice.

    • Cranraspberry says:

      Hi Jeanine,

      I’ve actually never tried Era! As for Persil, I definitely prefer the powder: the liquid is very sudsy in my water and also very strongly scented, so I don’t use it much. However, if you’re used to liquids you might find that clothes come out not as soft as with a liquid detergent, and for some that can be a deal breaker.

      If you’re mostly happy with Era, another option would be to add a booster – something like Oxiclean (there’s an unscented version for kids available if you prefer that), Oxo-Brite (this is on my “try next” list, best price I’ve found is on Vitacost: http://www.vitacost.com/earth-friendly-oxo-brite-for-laundry-and-stain-removal), Biz powder (the most cool water friendly of the bunch – the others require warm to hot water to work) or pure sodium percarbonate. You could either do a prewash/presoak with it or add some to the drum for the main wash. I know that I can’t be bothered to pretreat individual stains, so I stick with the presoak if I know I have some tough ones! Somehow that feels like much less of a hassle.

  4. Vallery Minozevski says:

    the sodium percarbonate you link is not availabe.. do you suggest in staying with a “kosher” one or does it matter?? ps love persil.. bought some “accidently” when a bag was marked way down on the open containers in the amazon warehouse and i’ve really been wondering if the ones at walmart were the same… thanks for your research!!!

    • Cranraspberry says:

      Hi Vallery!
      Oh sorry about that, I’ll make sure to get that link fixed. Here are a couple of options for you: 2 lb bag, 5 lb bag, both with free shipping.
      For laundry there’s really not a huge difference between kosher and non-kosher when it comes to sodium percarbonate. Both are s.p. in pure form with no added filler.

      The German Persil is a little different from the Walmart one – the ingredients are not identical, however the scent is the same. I’d love to hear what you think of the ProClean when you purchase it!

  5. Vallery Minozevski says:

    actually after reading your review i bought some last night.. i’ve only done one load, but so far so good.. i realize they are different, but it looks like the walmart form does a pretty good job for the price difference.. i am using the power caps, but i am planning on trying the powders in the future.. my husband is very very funny about smells and he sweats alot, and his main complaint was the clothes always smelled dirty and they came out with alot of hair (mine) sticking to them. the persil seems to clean without these issues..

  6. Camilla says:

    That was funny.I don’t know who would use used toilet paper unelss it was to recycle in the recycling worm cannisters to make good soil for flowers.I was going to put a blog on it because if people recycled everything from their homes, gardens would be beautiful and dumps would have less garbage dumped into them.

  7. Debra says:

    Does the Persil power pearls contain optical brighteners like the liquid version does? Which would be better to use on darks? Thanks!

    • Olga says:

      Hi Debra,
      All of the Persil ProClean detergents contain OBAs, so I personally do not use them for darks. If you’re looking for a reasonably priced powder with no OBAs, you could look into Cheer or the more expensive German version of Persil Color Megaperls.

    • Olga says:

      Hey Dan, it’s a Miele W3038! I actually have a pretty long blog post about it over here with all the details if you’re interested to find out more.

  8. anna says:

    hi there, i have a quick question for you. if you are doing non-white dress shirts like blue or patterned, do you use the hot setting? i’ve been washing in warm but still get some yellow pit stains and was hoping a hotter setting would do the trick. thanks!

    • Olga says:

      Hi Anna! I wash light blue and thin stripe/check dress shirts along with whites at 120F/50C which is the Very Warm setting on my washer. My husband doesn’t have any bright dress shirts where fading or color bleed would be an issue, so can’t speak to those.

      Not sure how hot your Hot setting gets, but I’d give it a go. Do you pre-treat the stains at all? That might be a good option for more saturated colors, also a warm soak overnight should help for anything you don’t want to expose to Hot.

      • anna says:

        thank you for the quick and detailed response! yes, light blue and striped is what i meant. good to know you wash in very warm. i’m assuming that’s my hot. i have a whirlpool duet with steam clean feature. i think it’s a good machine but i’m not sure if i’m using it to its full potential. the instruction manual doesn’t offer much (though one would think a washer would be fairly self explanatory lol). i do pretreat sometimes but i will admit i’m a lazy launderer. i recently purchased the clorox 2 spray pre treat so we’ll see how that works. i also presoak but one thing my machine doesn’t have is a separate detergent dispenser for presoaking. i think it takes the detergent from the main wash, uses it for soaking, then continues onto the wash.

  9. Olga O says:

    Hi Olga! I came across your blog while researching Persil v Tide. My parents started using Persil recently and when I walked into their house my first comment was, “It smells like Europe!” (where we’re from originally). That SMELL!
    I’m looking forward to giving it a go, since the Tide Free is not quite cutting it anymore. Thanks for your great blog with all the info. I feel like I can up my laundry game considerably now, and will check around for both the classic and the Color versions.

  10. Beki says:

    Hello I found you because of a comment you made re lines on caps of detergent bottles being hard to read. I have been comparing amounts of liquid in Tide caps and have been attempting to save as much liquid as possible without throwing cap into wash AND ways to clean the nasty cup. I just squeezed the lady amount out of a hole I punched in the bottle.
    Anyways, how does Tide with Febreze compare to Persil?
    I have never heard of this brand.
    Thank you

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *